Reddit Could Be a Goldmine for Marketers | Anthony Holiday of Sitka Design

web design
Marketing Leaders
Communication
September 18, 2025
Anthony Holiday

If you’ve written off Reddit as a noisy forum (or a spam trap), this episode will change your mind. In a “feed interrupt” conversation, Anthony breaks down how he’s using Reddit (and Quora/forums) to find real demand, ship answers people actually need, and turn those answers into qualified leads—including a case study in luxury real estate where inbound inquiries spiked without dropping a single link.

Episode Overview

We unpack a practical, low-risk way to use Reddit for search-led growth:

  • Why Reddit is secretly a search engine for intent (and why most users lurk)
  • How to source high-signal questions that deserve content
  • The format for posting answers without getting flagged as spam
  • Why profile-level credibility beats link-dropping
  • A luxury real estate play: answering hyper-local, high-intent questions that convert

Key Takeaways

  • Reddit ≠ random chatter. It’s a massive Q&A search layer. Treat it like user research and distribution rolled into one.
  • Answer the question, don’t pitch. Most redditors lurk; they read and click profiles. Your username and history are your “links.”
  • Hyper-specific > broad. Go deep on niche questions (location, price bands, tool quirks, edge cases).
  • Repurpose with intent. Turn recurring questions into posts, YouTube videos, and site articles—then reference them in community replies.
  • Mind the mods. Each subreddit has different rules. Lead with value, disclose context, and avoid salesy language.

The Reddit-to-Revenue Loop (Simple Framework)

  1. Mine Questions: Search Reddit/Quora/forums for recurring, unanswered, or poorly answered questions in your niche.
  2. Make the Asset: Create a crisp, specific answer (post, short video, or blog).
  3. Post Natively: Reply in the original thread with a complete answer. Keep links out or place only one helpful link when rules allow.
  4. Profile Credibility: Use a profession-forward handle (e.g., Name_Realtor). Readers click profiles—treat your profile as your “about/links” page.
  5. Schema + SEO: Publish the fuller version on your site with FAQ/schema to capture search lift.
  6. Rinse & Expand: Track the questions that consistently drive profile views, DMs, and inquiries. Make more of those.

Episode Timestamps

  • 00:00 – Why this “feed interrupt” episode matters (Reddit results that surprised us)
  • 01:19 – Polls, pulse-checking, and Anthony’s “post every weekday” rule
  • 02:19 – The discovery: answering very specific Reddit questions → big views
  • 04:36 – The lurker effect: most users don’t post—they read and click profiles
  • 05:28 – What to answer? Curiosity + recurring questions beat vanity topics
  • 06:40 – Where to hunt: niche subreddits, Quora, product forums, dev boards
  • 08:27 – Do you drop links? Why profiles > links for trust and leads
  • 09:23 – Reddit’s search power (even surfacing in AI-assisted results)
  • 11:00 – Time investment, posting across subs, and mod risk
  • 11:25 – Every subreddit is different—how to avoid the spam hammer
  • 12:46 – Contribute first: the “would a mod call this helpful?” test
  • 13:30 – Luxury real estate case study: hyper-local questions that convert
  • 15:00 – Turning answers into site content + schema for search lift
  • 16:10 – Why this works in any niche (tools, Webflow, JS, etc.)

The Luxury Real Estate Play (Explained)

Context: High-end realtor in a ski town (BC, Canada). Targets $1.5M–$30M properties.
Plan:

  • Publish hyper-local guides (“best restaurants in [neighborhood],” “safest areas for families,” “school districts by price band”).
  • Mirror those topics to Reddit/Quora threads where people ask exactly those questions (“Moving to [city] from [state]—which area?”).
  • Answer fully in-thread, using a professional handle (e.g., Name_Realtor), and let curious readers click to the profile and site.

Result: A visible uptick in qualified inquiries—because the questions came from people already in-market.

Swipe This: Reddit Answer Template (Non-Spammy)

“I live/work in [city] and help buyers in [neighborhoods].
For families, I’d shortlist:
[Area 1]: newer builds, lower crime, quick access to [amenity].
[Area 2]: older homes with character; top-rated [school].
[Area 3]: best for walkability and restaurants.
Watch for: HOA rules in [area], winter road closures near [landmark].
If you share budget + timeline, I can narrow this to 2–3 streets.”

No pitch. No hard link. Pure help. Your profile does the rest.

Light SEO to Pair with Reddit

  • Turn each recurring question into a blog post with an H1 matching the query and FAQ schema for sub-questions.
  • Add internal links from related posts (e.g., neighborhood → schools → restaurants).
  • Embed a short YouTube answer when it helps—great for both SERP and repurposing.

Guest Links

Add from your project folder (and update before publishing):

Free Homepage Breakdown

Is your homepage answering the questions your best buyers are already asking on Reddit?

👉 Get your Free Homepage Breakdown (Normally $500): https://www.mmgdesign.net/free-audit

I’ll show you how to translate real buyer questions into homepage sections that clarify, differentiate, and convert.

More Episodes

entry 021

spotify logo
No items found.

Entry 028

spotify logo

Entry 013

spotify logo

entry 010

spotify logo

ENTRY 024

spotify logo
No items found.

entry 003

spotify logo